Shin Tae-yong Dinilai Hanya Pelatih Biasa Tanpa Pemain Diaspora

Rais Adnan

Editor: Rais Adnan

Pelatih Timnas Indonesia, Shin Tae-yong. (Foto PSSI/Grafis Jovi Arnanda/Skor.id)
Pelatih Timnas Indonesia, Shin Tae-yong. (Foto: PSSI/Grafis Jovi Arnanda/Skor.id)

SKOR.id - Shin Tae-yong (STY) sebagai pelatih dinilai gagal dalam meramu Timnas Indonesia yang diisi para pemain muda yang mayoritas masih berusia di bawah 22 tahun.

Hal itu berdasarkan penilaian pengamat sepak bola Kesit Budi Handoyo, usai Timnas Indonesia gagal ke semifinal ASEAN Championship 2024.

Skuad Garuda dipastikan gagal ke semifinal setelah kalah dari Filipina pada laga terakhir Grup B. Dalam laga yang digelar di Stadion Manahan, Solo, Sabtu (21/12/2024) malam WIB, itu Timnas Indonesia kalah dengan skor tipis 0-1.

Gol tunggal kemenangan Filipina dicetak melalui tendangan penalti Bjorn Martin Kristensen pada menit ke-63. 

Menurut Kesit, torehan buruk ini menguatkan kesan bahwa kualitas pelatih Korea Selatan itu tergolong biasa. 

"Bukan maksud membedakan, namun terlihat bagaimana ketika strategi dan taktik tidak bisa berjalan tanpa ditunjang kualitas pemain, maka mutu pelatih pun akan kelihatan. Tanpa pemain diaspora yang sudah didatangkan PSSI, terlihat STY gak bisa apa-apa," ujarnya.

Pertandingan Indonesia vs Filipina di babak pertama berlangsung cukup sengit. Intensitas permainan yang tinggi membuat beberapa pelanggaran tak terhindarkan.

Total, ada 16 pelanggaran yang terjadi selama interval pertama dengan empat kartu kuning dan satu kartu merah. Satu kartu merah didapatkan bek Timnas Indonesia, Muhammad Ferarri, setelah menyikut pemain Filipina di kotak penalti The Azkals.

Bermain dengan 10 pemain, Indonesia mulai menyerang sejak babak kedua dimulai. Namun, gawang Indonesia justru kebobolan melalui tendangan penalti Kristensen setelah tendangan Tabinas mengenai tangan Dony Tri Pamungkas di kotak penalti. Skor 0-1 untuk Filipina.

Pemain Indonesia mencoba untuk merespons gol tersebut. Namun hingga peluit panjang dibunyikan, skor 1-0 untuk kemenangan Filipina tak berubah.

"Memang Timnas di ASEAN Championship 2024 ini tergolong muda, dengan mayoritas di bawah 22 tahun. Tapi, sejak laga pertama melawan Myanmar, lalu Laos, Vietnam, dan Filipina, permainan mereka tidak berkembang. STY memang mengalami kesulitan ketika dia hanya mengandalkan pemain lokal yang jam terbangnya sedikit, berbeda dengan pemain Timnas yang di dominasi pemain diaspora," jelas Kesit.

Pada sisi lain, kemenangan ini membuat Filipina mendampingi Vietnam dari Grup B untuk lolos ke semifinal. Pada babak semifinal, Filipina berjumpa dengan Thailand yang menjadi juara Grup A. Sedangkan Vietnam ditantang Singapura yang merupakan runner-up Grup A.

RELATED STORIES

Hasil Timnas Indonesia vs Filipina: Ferarri Kartu Merah, Garuda Kalah dan Tersingkir

Hasil Timnas Indonesia vs Filipina: Ferarri Kartu Merah, Garuda Kalah dan Tersingkir

Timnas Indonesia gagal lolos ke semifinal ASEAN Championship 2024 usai kalah 0-1 dari Filpina di laga penentuan Grup B, Sabtu (21/12/2024) malam.

ASEAN Championship 2024: Jadwal, Hasil dan Klasemen Lengkap

Jadwal, hasil, dan klasemen ASEAN Championship 2024, yang terus diperbarui seiring berjalannya turnamen.

Skor co creators network
RIGHT_ARROW
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
PLAY_ICON
RIGHT_ARROW

THE LATEST

Liga 1

Suntikan Energi Baru, Persija Resmi Berkolaborasi dengan Hyundai

Persija berharap kerja sama dengan Hyundai bisa berlangsung dengan kurun waktu yang lama.

Sumargo Pangestu | 09 Oct, 09:57

Malaysia Diumumkan Jadi Tuan Rumah IESF WEC 2025 game Mobile Legends. (Grafis: Deni Sulaeman/Skor.id)

Esports

Timnas MLBB Indonesia Siapkan yang Terbaik untuk IESF WEC 2025

Kejuaraan Esports Dunia IESF 2025 akan berlangsung di Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia, pada 1-7 Desember 2025 mendatang.

Gangga Basudewa | 09 Oct, 09:57

Kompetisi futsal kasta tertinggi di Indonesia, Pro Futsal League 2025-2026. (Kevin Bagus Prinusa/Skor.id)

Futsal

Pro Futsal League 2025-2026: Jadwal, Hasil dan Klasemen Lengkap

Jadwal, hasil, dan klasemen Pro Futsal League 2025-2026 yang terus diperbaharui seiring berjalannya kompetisi.

Taufani Rahmanda | 09 Oct, 08:13

Kompetisi sepak bola kasta kedua di Indonesia atau Championship 2025-2026 untuk Grup 2. (Deni Sulaeman/Skor.id)

Liga 2

Prediksi dan Link Live Streaming Championship 2025-2026: Grup 2 Pekan Kelima

Persiku vs Barito, Persipal vs PSIS, Deltras vs Persipura, PSS vs Tornado FC, dan Persiba vs Persela pada Jumat-Minggu (10-12/10/2025).

Taufani Rahmanda | 09 Oct, 07:42

Identitas baru dari kompetisi sepak bola kasta tertinggi di Indonesia atau Liga 1 di musim ini, Super League 2025-2026. (Deni Sulaeman/Skor.id)

Liga 1

Super League 2025-2026: Jadwal, Hasil, Klasemen dan Profil Klub Lengkap

Jadwal, hasil, dan klasemen Super League 2025-2026 yang terus diperbarui seiring bergulirnya kompetisi, plus profil tim peserta.

Taufani Rahmanda | 09 Oct, 06:53

Kompetisi sepak bola kasta kedua di Indonesia atau identitas baru dari Liga 2 musim terbaru, Championship 2025-2026. (Deni Sulaeman/Skor.id)

Liga 2

Championship 2025-2026: Jadwal, Hasil dan Klasemen Lengkap

Jadwal, hasil, dan klasemen Liga 2 atau Championship 2025-2026 yang terus diperbarui seiring bergulirnya kompetisi.

Taufani Rahmanda | 09 Oct, 06:52

Logo PBSI

Badminton

Tunjuk EO Kompetisi Bulu Tangkis untuk 2026, PBSI Gandeng PT Perada Swara Productions

PBSI menilai PT Perada Swara Productions melalui Megapro Communications berpengalaman mengurusi ajang bulu tangkis.

Taufani Rahmanda | 09 Oct, 06:52

Penyerang Real Madrid, Kylian Mbappe, mendapat penghargaan dari LaLiga di bulan September 2025. (Foto: LaLiga. Grafis: Deni Sulaeman/Skor.id).

La Liga

3 Pemain Real Madrid Raih Penghargaan di Bulan September dari La Liga

Ada 3 pemain Real Madrid yang mendapat penghargaan di bulan September 2025, termasuk Kylian Mbappe.

Pradipta Indra Kumara | 09 Oct, 04:48

Pelatih Timnas Arab Saudi, Herve Renard. (Foto: Sumargo Pangestu/Grafis: Dede Sopatal Mauladi/Skor.id)

Timnas Indonesia

Menang Atas Timnas Indonesia, Pelatih Arab Saudi Ingin Pemainnya Tidak Cepat Puas

Pelatih Timnas Arab Saudi, Herve Renard, juga menyoroti timnya yang banyak membuang peluang saat melawan Indonesia.

Rais Adnan | 09 Oct, 03:13

Cristiano Ronaldo bertahan di Al Nassr. (Grafis: Deni Sulaeman/Skor.id).

World

Dinobatkan Jadi Pesepak Bola Miliarder Pertama, Kekayaan Cristiano Ronaldo Jauh Melebihi Lionel Messi

Berdasarkan laporan terbaru Bloomberg, kekayaan bersih Ronaldo mencapai Rp22,7 triliun!

Rais Adnan | 09 Oct, 01:59

Load More Articles